Difference between revisions of "What was the impact of the Paris Commune of 1871 on Revolutionaries"
m (Admin moved page What was the impact of the Paris Commune of 1871 on Revolutionaries? to What was the impact of the Paris Commune of 1871 on Revolutionaries) |
|||
| (5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | <youtube>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ya8cSGAiEyw</youtube> | ||
__NOTOC__ | __NOTOC__ | ||
| − | [[File:Paris_Commune_rue_de_Rivoli.jpg|thumbnail| | + | [[File:Paris_Commune_rue_de_Rivoli.jpg|thumbnail|250px|left|Rue de Rivoli in Paris a week after the fires abated]] |
| − | In 1871, in Paris, there was one of the first modern left-wing revolutions in the world. It came amidst a background of war and siege. The Paris Commune as the revolution was known, sought to implement some of the most radical ideas of the French Revolution. The revolutionaries were much influenced by anarchism and were | + | In 1871, in Paris, there was one of the first modern left-wing revolutions in the world. It came amidst a background of war and siege. The Paris Commune, as the revolution was known, sought to implement some of the most radical ideas of the French Revolution. The revolutionaries were much influenced by anarchism and were the precursors of the Soviet Communist in Russian in the early 20th century. The Paris Commune was ultimately defeated, but it served as a model for many revolutionaries at the time and to the present day. |
====Background==== | ====Background==== | ||
| − | In 1870, the Prussian Chancellor Bismarck engineered a war with France, under its Emperor Napoleon III. The two nations fought each other mainly in north-eastern France. The Prussians and their German allies defeated the French at the Battle of Sedan and captured the Emperor and they then proceeded to besiege Paris. In the city, the local | + | In 1870, the Prussian Chancellor Bismarck engineered a war with France, under its Emperor Napoleon III. The two nations fought each other, mainly in north-eastern France. The Prussians and their German allies defeated the French at the Battle of Sedan and captured the Emperor, and they then proceeded to besiege Paris. In the city, the local defense was often in the local militia, the National Guard, and organized based on neighborhoods. At this time, many Paris citizens, especially in the poorer neighborhoods, effectively governed themselves, as they were cut off from the central government's control during the Prussian siege. |
| − | A new provisional French government was located in Bordeaux, far in the South-West of France. Many | + | A new provisional French government was located in Bordeaux, far in the South-West of France. Many of the National Guard members had left-wing sympathies, and they had long resented the autocratic rule of Napoleon III and were eager for change. <ref>Edwards, Stewart. ''[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0812902599/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=0812902599&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=0f4c18f751d6a03db9b795cba08fd648 The Paris Commune 1871]''. (London: Eyre & Spottiswoode, 1971), p. 67.</ref> Many of the more radical elements in the National Guard were radicals and wanted a revolution. Many of these were sympathetic to the first Socialist movement, the ‘First International.’ <ref>Stewart, p. 68.</ref> Many in Paris felt abandoned by the new French government and angry at their handling of the war effort. |
| − | There was growing frustration with the French army and the government for failing to lift the Prussian siege | + | There was growing frustration with the French army and the government for failing to lift the Prussian siege. After a large demonstration, the National Guard seized control of the government of the city.<ref>Cobban, Alfred, ''[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/014020525X/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=014020525X&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=982f548e95ba459e58a23f0b79e6726c A History of Modern France]'' (Hammondsworth, Penguin Books, 1965), p. 215.</ref> They began to organize the city's government on Socialist and Anarchist lines and were committed to Paris's defense against the besieging Germans. The Communards, as they became known, organized an election, which they won. They organized the city on socialist principles, and power was located with local committees.<ref>Cobban, p. 217.</ref> |
| − | The rebels demanded a separation of Church and State, universal suffrage and some | + | The rebels demanded a separation of Church and State, universal suffrage, and some demanded even abolishing all private property. They also wanted the power to rest with the people and their local committees. The rebels saw themselves as the heirs of the Great French Revolutionaries such as Marat and Danton. As they became known, the Communards defied the new French government and sought to extend their rule throughout France.<ref>Merman, John (2014). ''[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0465020178/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=0465020178&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=8b30415300c9c2d08b9fb770bbab6922 Massacre: The Life and Death of the Paris Commune of 1871]''. (New Haven and London: Yale University Press). p. 81.</ref> |
====The Suppression of the Communards==== | ====The Suppression of the Communards==== | ||
[[File:1184px-Commune_de_Paris_barricade_Place_Blanche.jpg|thumbnail|365px|The barricade on Blanche Place in Paris, 1871]] | [[File:1184px-Commune_de_Paris_barricade_Place_Blanche.jpg|thumbnail|365px|The barricade on Blanche Place in Paris, 1871]] | ||
| − | After the French government agreed to a peace treaty with the Germans, the war between it and the Communards was inevitable. The new French government, under Adolphe Thiers, decided to crush the Communards and their movement. | + | After the French government agreed to a peace treaty with the Germans, the war between it and the Communards was inevitable. The new French government, under Adolphe Thiers, decided to crush the Communards and their movement. They dispatched a large military force to Paris with secret German help, occupying territory around France. <ref>Cobain, p. 218.</ref> When the Communards refused to hand over some cannon to the French army, this was to provide the French army with the excuse it needed to crush the National Guard and all those who supported the Paris Commune. |
| − | The French army bombarded the Communards in Paris and then attacked their strongholds. The rebels resisted furiously and the fighting became known as the ‘Bloody | + | The French army bombarded the Communards in Paris and then attacked their strongholds. The rebels resisted furiously, and the fighting became known as the ‘Bloody Week.’ The French army brutally crushed the rebels, and it summarily executed many Communards. The rebels had also committed many atrocities, including the execution of priests. At the end of the fighting, some 18,000 people had died, and 25,000 were wounded. Many Communards were imprisoned and sent to Penal Colonies in French Guinea.<ref>Merman, p. 134.</ref> The French Government was able to reassert its control over Paris. Soon after the Communards were crushed, the Prussians withdrew from France. |
====Influence of the Paris Commune on Revolutionaries==== | ====Influence of the Paris Commune on Revolutionaries==== | ||
| − | The Communards were | + | The Communards were destroyed; however, their revolt and their ideology were to have an enormous influence. They were to inspire many revolutionaries from all over Europe. They saw in the Communard’s rebellion an example of how a society could liberate itself from the forces of oppression, such as the Church and Monarchy. They saw the Communards as providing a model for a future and free society, where equality and justice were guaranteed.<ref>Cobain, p. 218.</ref> Nearly every revolutionary movement in the period drew important lessons from the Parisian Revolutionaries. Their bloody suppression of the revolution persuaded many that change was only possible through violence. As a result, in the decades following the Communards' defeat, many radical groups engaged in terrorist attacks across Europe, but especially in the Russian Empire, where terrorist groups such as the People’s Will launched bombings and assassinations campaign.<ref> Butterworth, Alex. ''[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0307386759/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=0307386759&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=a91bd1a2ab2e4468679c38c61138cffc The World That Never Was: A True Story of Dreamers, Schemers, Anarchists, and Secret Police]'' (Pantheon Books, London, 2010), p. 4, 7, 14.</ref> |
====Influence on Marx and Lenin==== | ====Influence on Marx and Lenin==== | ||
| − | [[File:683px-Lenin.jpg|thumbnail| | + | [[File:683px-Lenin.jpg|thumbnail|255px|left|Vladimir Lenin]] |
| − | Almost immediately after the defeat of the Communards, left-wing radicals | + | Almost immediately after the defeat of the Communards, left-wing radicals analyzed why the revolution had failed. These critiques were very influential. None more so than that of Karl Marx, the founder of Communism. He studied the reasons for the revolt's failure and published his findings in his work the Civil War in France (1871).<ref> Karl Marx, ''The Civil War in France, English Edition of 1871'', p. 1.</ref> He believed that the Commune failed because it was not ruthless enough and that if some professional revolutionaries should have led it. Marx believed that the Commune was the first example of the ‘dictatorship of the proletariat,’ a form of participatory government, where all power was in ordinary people's hands.<ref>Marx, 6.</ref> |
| − | The Communards and their revolution were to have a huge influence on Lenin. The Russian Revolutionary studied the works of Marx on the history of the Communards. He came to the conclusion that professional revolutionaries were needed to ensure that a revolution would succeed and not be quashed as were the Communards. Lenin was also influenced by | + | The Communards and their revolution were to have a huge influence on Lenin. The Russian Revolutionary studied the works of Marx on the history of the Communards. He came to the conclusion that professional revolutionaries were needed to ensure that a revolution would succeed and not be quashed as were the Communards. Lenin was also influenced by the Communards' organization and wrote extensively on their ideas and revolution.<ref> V.I. Lenin, "Lessons of the Commune," Marxists Internet Archive. Originally published: Zagranichnaya Gazeta, No. 2, 23 March 1908. Translated by Bernard Isaacs.</ref> He modeled his Soviets or workers’ councils on the democratic councils established by the French Revolutionaries in 1871. The revolution of 1871 was to have an important influence on the Russian Revolution in 1917. |
====Conclusion==== | ====Conclusion==== | ||
| − | The Paris Commune was a failed revolution. It attempted to | + | The Paris Commune was a failed revolution. It attempted to fulfill the more radical ideas of the French Revolution in 1789. It was savagely repressed, and there was to be no similar revolution in France until 1968. The Communards' repression encouraged many left-wing groups to adopt more violent tactics, and in the decades after the revolt, terrorism became a feature of European life. The ideas and the Commune of 1871 example were to have a decisive influence on both Marx and Lenin and continues to this day, in left-wing circles. |
<div class="portal" style="width:85%;"> | <div class="portal" style="width:85%;"> | ||
====Related DailyHistory.org Articles==== | ====Related DailyHistory.org Articles==== | ||
*[[What were the goals of the Axis powers and the Soviet Union during World War Two?]] | *[[What were the goals of the Axis powers and the Soviet Union during World War Two?]] | ||
| − | |||
*[[Why did Operation Market Garden in 1944 fail?]] | *[[Why did Operation Market Garden in 1944 fail?]] | ||
*[[How did Mussolini become Prime Minister of Italy?]] | *[[How did Mussolini become Prime Minister of Italy?]] | ||
| − | *[[ | + | *[[How did Adolf Hitler become the Fuhrer of Germany?]] |
*[[Why did Germany lose the Battle of Stalingrad?]] | *[[Why did Germany lose the Battle of Stalingrad?]] | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
Latest revision as of 06:04, 13 September 2021
In 1871, in Paris, there was one of the first modern left-wing revolutions in the world. It came amidst a background of war and siege. The Paris Commune, as the revolution was known, sought to implement some of the most radical ideas of the French Revolution. The revolutionaries were much influenced by anarchism and were the precursors of the Soviet Communist in Russian in the early 20th century. The Paris Commune was ultimately defeated, but it served as a model for many revolutionaries at the time and to the present day.
Background
In 1870, the Prussian Chancellor Bismarck engineered a war with France, under its Emperor Napoleon III. The two nations fought each other, mainly in north-eastern France. The Prussians and their German allies defeated the French at the Battle of Sedan and captured the Emperor, and they then proceeded to besiege Paris. In the city, the local defense was often in the local militia, the National Guard, and organized based on neighborhoods. At this time, many Paris citizens, especially in the poorer neighborhoods, effectively governed themselves, as they were cut off from the central government's control during the Prussian siege.
A new provisional French government was located in Bordeaux, far in the South-West of France. Many of the National Guard members had left-wing sympathies, and they had long resented the autocratic rule of Napoleon III and were eager for change. [1] Many of the more radical elements in the National Guard were radicals and wanted a revolution. Many of these were sympathetic to the first Socialist movement, the ‘First International.’ [2] Many in Paris felt abandoned by the new French government and angry at their handling of the war effort.
There was growing frustration with the French army and the government for failing to lift the Prussian siege. After a large demonstration, the National Guard seized control of the government of the city.[3] They began to organize the city's government on Socialist and Anarchist lines and were committed to Paris's defense against the besieging Germans. The Communards, as they became known, organized an election, which they won. They organized the city on socialist principles, and power was located with local committees.[4]
The rebels demanded a separation of Church and State, universal suffrage, and some demanded even abolishing all private property. They also wanted the power to rest with the people and their local committees. The rebels saw themselves as the heirs of the Great French Revolutionaries such as Marat and Danton. As they became known, the Communards defied the new French government and sought to extend their rule throughout France.[5]
The Suppression of the Communards
After the French government agreed to a peace treaty with the Germans, the war between it and the Communards was inevitable. The new French government, under Adolphe Thiers, decided to crush the Communards and their movement. They dispatched a large military force to Paris with secret German help, occupying territory around France. [6] When the Communards refused to hand over some cannon to the French army, this was to provide the French army with the excuse it needed to crush the National Guard and all those who supported the Paris Commune.
The French army bombarded the Communards in Paris and then attacked their strongholds. The rebels resisted furiously, and the fighting became known as the ‘Bloody Week.’ The French army brutally crushed the rebels, and it summarily executed many Communards. The rebels had also committed many atrocities, including the execution of priests. At the end of the fighting, some 18,000 people had died, and 25,000 were wounded. Many Communards were imprisoned and sent to Penal Colonies in French Guinea.[7] The French Government was able to reassert its control over Paris. Soon after the Communards were crushed, the Prussians withdrew from France.
Influence of the Paris Commune on Revolutionaries
The Communards were destroyed; however, their revolt and their ideology were to have an enormous influence. They were to inspire many revolutionaries from all over Europe. They saw in the Communard’s rebellion an example of how a society could liberate itself from the forces of oppression, such as the Church and Monarchy. They saw the Communards as providing a model for a future and free society, where equality and justice were guaranteed.[8] Nearly every revolutionary movement in the period drew important lessons from the Parisian Revolutionaries. Their bloody suppression of the revolution persuaded many that change was only possible through violence. As a result, in the decades following the Communards' defeat, many radical groups engaged in terrorist attacks across Europe, but especially in the Russian Empire, where terrorist groups such as the People’s Will launched bombings and assassinations campaign.[9]
Influence on Marx and Lenin
Almost immediately after the defeat of the Communards, left-wing radicals analyzed why the revolution had failed. These critiques were very influential. None more so than that of Karl Marx, the founder of Communism. He studied the reasons for the revolt's failure and published his findings in his work the Civil War in France (1871).[10] He believed that the Commune failed because it was not ruthless enough and that if some professional revolutionaries should have led it. Marx believed that the Commune was the first example of the ‘dictatorship of the proletariat,’ a form of participatory government, where all power was in ordinary people's hands.[11]
The Communards and their revolution were to have a huge influence on Lenin. The Russian Revolutionary studied the works of Marx on the history of the Communards. He came to the conclusion that professional revolutionaries were needed to ensure that a revolution would succeed and not be quashed as were the Communards. Lenin was also influenced by the Communards' organization and wrote extensively on their ideas and revolution.[12] He modeled his Soviets or workers’ councils on the democratic councils established by the French Revolutionaries in 1871. The revolution of 1871 was to have an important influence on the Russian Revolution in 1917.
Conclusion
The Paris Commune was a failed revolution. It attempted to fulfill the more radical ideas of the French Revolution in 1789. It was savagely repressed, and there was to be no similar revolution in France until 1968. The Communards' repression encouraged many left-wing groups to adopt more violent tactics, and in the decades after the revolt, terrorism became a feature of European life. The ideas and the Commune of 1871 example were to have a decisive influence on both Marx and Lenin and continues to this day, in left-wing circles.
Related DailyHistory.org Articles
References
- ↑ Edwards, Stewart. The Paris Commune 1871. (London: Eyre & Spottiswoode, 1971), p. 67.
- ↑ Stewart, p. 68.
- ↑ Cobban, Alfred, A History of Modern France (Hammondsworth, Penguin Books, 1965), p. 215.
- ↑ Cobban, p. 217.
- ↑ Merman, John (2014). Massacre: The Life and Death of the Paris Commune of 1871. (New Haven and London: Yale University Press). p. 81.
- ↑ Cobain, p. 218.
- ↑ Merman, p. 134.
- ↑ Cobain, p. 218.
- ↑ Butterworth, Alex. The World That Never Was: A True Story of Dreamers, Schemers, Anarchists, and Secret Police (Pantheon Books, London, 2010), p. 4, 7, 14.
- ↑ Karl Marx, The Civil War in France, English Edition of 1871, p. 1.
- ↑ Marx, 6.
- ↑ V.I. Lenin, "Lessons of the Commune," Marxists Internet Archive. Originally published: Zagranichnaya Gazeta, No. 2, 23 March 1908. Translated by Bernard Isaacs.