What was the purpose of the Committee of Secret Correspondence during the American Revolution?
The Continental Congress established the Committee of Secret Correspondence to communicate with sympathetic Britons and other Europeans early in the American Revolution. The committee coordinated diplomatic functions for the Continental Congress and directed transatlantic communication and public relations.
The Committee of Secret Correspondence became the Committee of Foreign Affairs in April 1777 but retained its intelligence functions. As the first American government agency for both foreign intelligence and diplomatic representation, it may be regarded as a forerunner of both the State Department and the Central Intelligence Agency, as well as Congress’s current intelligence oversight committees. The Committee served an essential and critical function for Congress, it became the eyes and ears of the country in Europe.
Congress Communicates with Allies in Europe through the Committee
Congress initially established the Committee of Correspondence on November 29, 1775, to communicate with colonial agents in Britain and “friends in ... other parts of the world.” On the committee were Benjamin Franklin, Benjamin Harrison, Thomas Johnson, John Dickinson, and John Jay. Robert Morris, the revolutionary financier, soon joined them. Congress granted the committee extensive authority to conduct international diplomacy, including the negotiation of clandestine shipments of arms and other similar activities. Owing to the nature of the correspondence, the members began to add the word “secret” to the committee’s title, and soon it was known as the Committee of Secret Correspondence. The Committee's diplomatic duties grew, and Congress renamed it the Committee for Foreign Affairs on April 17, 1777.
Of the initial members of the committee, Benjamin Franklin was the most active. Drawing on his extensive European contacts, he began a campaign to rally international support of the American cause. On December 12, 1775, Franklin wrote to Don Gabriel de Bourbon, a prince of the Spanish royal family and one of Franklin's scholarly associates. In his letter, Franklin strongly hinted at the advantages of a Spanish alliance with the American revolutionaries. Franklin dispatched similar letters to American sympathizers in France. He sent these letters through associates whom he trusted to protect the communications from interception by the British.
Franklin, the only member with experience in foreign affairs, dominated the Committee, corresponding with friends in Europe and sounding out the possibility of an alliance with America. The French soon dispatched Julien Alexandre Achard de Bonvouloir to America to examine the feasibility of covert aid and political support, and the Committee sent its own secret agent, Silas Deane, to France for the same purposes in April 1776. Franklin himself left for Paris in late 1776 on his famous, and ultimately successful, mission to forge an alliance with France.
James Lovell was a teacher arrested by the British for spying after the Battle of Bunker Hill in 1775. He was exchanged later that next year for a British prisoner and was elected to the Continental Congress in 1777. While serving on the Committee of Secret Correspondence, Lovell was Congress’s expert on codes and ciphers and became known as the father of American cryptanalysis.
Arthur Lee, a Virginian living in London, also aided the Committee. Congress would later officially appoint Lee as a commissioner for the Committee. Lee had come into contact with the French playwright Beaumarchais, who was then working as a secret French agent investigating British troubles in the colonies. Lee provided Beaumarchais with information about American successes that influenced the French Foreign Minister Charles Gravier, Comte de Vergennes, to provide the colonies with clandestine shipments of gunpowder and war materiel.
Communicated with Foreign Agents in the Country
The Committee of Correspondence also worked on American soil. In late 1775, a mysterious French traveler named Achard de Bonvouloir appeared in Philadelphia. He had been dispatched by the French Government to contact the Continental Congress, but publicly disavowed any such mission. The committee made contact with him, and Franklin convinced Bonvouloir that the colonies were seeking independence and were unlikely to reconcile with Britain. Franklin encouraged this representative of the French Government to report to his government that France should seek an alliance with the colonies once they declared their independence, and in the meantime provide the colonies with secret assistance.
Thereafter, the Committee continued to correspond with Lee in London, and, after Congress appointed them in the fall of 1776, also with the commissioners in France. As the British Navy tightened its blockade, however, communication became increasingly difficult, especially after British forces seized Philadelphia in 1777. Once France formally signed an alliance with the United States in 1778, communications improved. With the alliance also came more duties for the Committee and the appointment of French Minister to the United States, Conrad-Alexandre Gérard de Rayneval.
- Why was the Jay Treaty so unpopular in the United States?
- How did the United States react to the French Revolution?
- Why did France side with the American Colonies during the American Revolution?
- What caused the French and Indian War?
- Why did the Continental Congress draft and sign the Declaration of Independence?
- How did the Treaty of Paris of 1783 end the American Revolution?
- Why did the Continental Congress adopt the Articles of Confederation?
- Why did the United States Continental Congress approve The Model Treaty of 1776?
- Why did Westward Expansion Lead to the American Revolution?
- How did Great Britain win the French Indian War (Seven Years War)?
- What was the Albany Plan of Union of 1754?
Committee resolved disputes between American foreign agents in Europe
The Committee also facilitated decisions to solve infighting among the American commissioners in Europe who clashed on financial matters. Lee suspected the early colonial agent in France, Silas Deane, of financial malfeasance and began a campaign to bring about his recall. Thomas Paine, who had become secretary of the Committee, sympathized with Lee. Paine published anonymous pamphlets in which he claimed that Congress possessed documentation of secret French aid that would affirm Lee’s version of events. French Minister Gérard intervened, explaining to the committee that France could not formally admit to providing such aid without risking war with Britain, which it was not ready to do. Congress passed a resolution denying that there had been French aid on January 12, 1778.
The Committee continued to coordinate communication between Congress and diplomats in Europe and sent more representatives to other European courts to encourage their assistance to the American cause. However, by 1780, an overworked Congress had many more duties, and members of the Committee for Foreign Affairs had begun to neglect their duties. Committee member James Lovell wrote to Arthur Lee and John Jay suggesting that Congress establish a Department of Foreign Affairs to handle the day-to-day business of foreign diplomacy. Congressman James Duane also agreed. The committee members brought the suggestion before Congress, and Congress ultimately decided to create a committee for the establishment of executive departments. Congress finally agreed to establish departments on February 6, 1781, but it was not until August 10 that the new Confederation Congress elected Robert Livingston as Secretary for Foreign Affairs.