Changes

Jump to: navigation, search

How historically accurate is the Gladiator?

5,633 bytes added, 02:50, 24 March 2021
no edit summary
<i>This article contains spoilers.</i>
__NOTOC__
[[File:Gladiator-3.jpeg|thumbnail|left|300px|The <i>Gladiator</i>]]
<i>[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00AEFY552/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B00AEFY552&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=ce0aef7b341cf998192101da595c6f64 Gladiator]</i> was a film released in 2000 starring Russell Crowe that focused on General Maximus Decimus Meridius, who was enslaved after escaping his execution for not supporting the new Roman emperor Commodus (starring Joaquin Phoenix). Maximus rises as a well-skilled gladiator, eventually making it to Rome, where he participates in the gladiator games sponsored by Commodus. After Commodus learns of Maximus, both characters want to kill the other. Maximus attempts to conspire with those in the Senate who dislike Commodus, while Commodus attempts to have Maximus killed in the gladiator battles.
==Battles in Germania==The <i>Gladiator</i> was a film released in 2000 starring Russell Crowe that focused on General Maximus Decimus Meridiusmovie begins with the ailing Marcus Aurelius, who was enslaved after escaping his execution for not supporting the new Roman Rome's emperor Commodus (staring Joaquin Phoenix), watching Maximus leading a battle against a German tribe. Maximus rises The battle is portrayed as a well skilled gladiator, eventually making it crucial in bringing peace to Rome where he participates in the gladiator games sponsored by CommodusRoman Empire's northern frontier. After Commodus learns of MaximusThe German tribe was shown wearing Neolithic period clothing, which is inaccurate, both characters want to kill and the otherclothing would have been more complex in fashion. Maximus attempts to conspire with those in During the Senate who dislike Commodusreign of Aurelius, while Commodus attempts to have Maximus killed there were prolonged wars in the gladiator battlesGermania.
Although they were close to annexing Moravia and West Slovakia during his reign, wars there were largely inconclusive. The movie depicts the emperor being killed by his son Commodus, although Commodus was already co-emperor. There is no evidence that Commodus had any difficult relationship with his father, although later authors did disparage Commodus. Furthermore, although Maximus is mostly a fictional character, it is not likely Marcus Aurelius would appoint a general as protector of the empire, as suggested in the movie where shortly before his death, the fictional Marcus Aurelius asked Maximus to lead the empire.  In fact, in the film, a conflict in Marcus Aurelius' mind was whether to return power to the Senate rather than have it mostly be with the emperor. This is unlikely as Marcus Aurelius, although often considered a wise emperor and even called the "philosopher-king," as suggested in the film, still believed in holding power closely and willingly passed power to his son, something a Roman Emperor had not done for about a century.<ref>For more on Marcus Aurelius, see Birley, A. R. (2016). <i>[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000FA62O8/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B000FA62O8&linkCode=as2&tag=Battles dailyh0c-20&linkId=aee0aa476daf8e04842311de39ecaef3 Marcus Aurelius: a biography].</i> Place of publication not identified: Routledge.</ref> Marcus Aurelius appointed his son as successor long before he died in 166 (he died in 180 CE), making it clear that Commodus was his choice all along. He also died in Vienna (ancient Vindobona), but the film showed him dying in Germaniaduring the campaign. Some rumors and stories did circulate that Commodus did kill his father, but this could have been later stories created to malign the emperor Commodus since he was not well-liked by the Senate, as suggested in the film. The appointment of Commodus was controversial, as shown in the film. From historical documents, mainly in the writings of Cassius Dio, there is an indication that Marcus Aurelius was disappointed in his son, suggesting he had some trepidation about him. Cassius Dio indicates that Rome suffered as Commodus came to power, but this could be part of later propaganda after Commodus's reign. It is hard to tell what is exactly accurate as Commodus may have been more disliked by the upper classes. At the same time, some indication suggests he was popular with the army or even lower classes as a sort of peoples' emperor.<ref>For more on Commodus and his life, see: Adams, G. W. (2013). <i>[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1612337228/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=1612337228&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=2642b1925a40b708465fd89d98d57316 Emperor Commodus: Gladiator, Hercules or a tyrant?]</i> Boca Raton: BrownWalker Press.</ref> ==Were the Gladiator Contests shown in Gladiator Accurate?==[[File:0 Colosseum - Rome 111001 (2).jpeg|thumbnail|left|300px|Figure 1. The Colosseum was the premier event for gladiator contests, where advertisement and billboards also hung to promote products.]]In the film, after Maximus was taken as a slave, but not before he discovered that Commodus killed his wife and son, he was shown as being transported and eventually enslaved as a gladiator in a far away, remote province in the Roman Empire (somewhere in the Middle East or North Africa). While the circumstances of how Commodus became emperor in the film are probably not true, there is some greater truth in some gladiator fights. For instance, gladiator contests did often reconstruct famous battles or scenes using characters from history or legends. Gladiator contests did take place in many places around the empire. Animals, such as tigers, were often used in arenas, where gladiators might fight each other and animals.  Excavations at the Colosseum showed a variety of exotic animals were present there. This included: bears, lions, hyenas, elephants, wild boar, buffalo, tigers, bulls, wolves, and leopards. The gladiators' clothing, particularly the helmets, were likely, not true and were stereotypes taken from later periods.<ref>For more on the gladiator games in the Roman Empire, see: Dunkle, R. (2008). <i>[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00ID6R2CW/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B00ID6R2CW&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=3e1905f472915347388e16545946008c Gladiators: violence and spectacle in ancient Rome].</i>. 1st ed. Harlow, England ; New York: Pearson/Longman.</ref>
The movie begins with the ailing Marcus AureliusGladiators, the emperor of Rome, watching Maximus leading a battle against a Germany tribe, where the battle is portrayed as crucial suggested in bringing peace to Roman Empire's northern frontier. During the reign of Aureliusfilm, there were prolonged wars in Germaniawe're treated like rock stars. Wars there Those who were largely inconclusivesuccessful could gain favors, although they were close such as having access to annexing Moravia women and West Slovakia during his reigneven earn their freedom. The movie depicts However, unlike the emperor being killed by his son Commodusfilm, although in reality Commodus was already co-emperor. In fact, there is no evidence that Commodus had any difficult relationship with his father. Furthermore, although Maximus is mostly a fictional character, it is contests often did not likely Marcus Aurelius would appoint a general as protector of the empire, as suggested result in the movie where shortly before his death the fictional Marcus Aurelius asked Maximus to lead the empireof contestants. In Animals, in fact, a conflict were more often killed in Marcus Aurlieus' mind was whether to return power to the Senate rather than contests. This may have it mostly be with been de-emphasized in the emperorfilm. This is unlikely as Marcus AurlieusThe emperors did use their thumbs at times to determine if a gladiator should die or live, although often considered we do not know if this was thumbs up for a wise emperor living and even called thumbs down for getting killed. It could have been the "philosopher kingother way around.<ref>For more on gladiator traditions," as suggested in the see Winkler, M. M. (Ed.). (, 2004). <i>[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1405110422/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=1405110422&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=0a0147f269beb6328eb63b9d10801203 Gladiator: film, he still believed in holding power closely and even passed power to his sonhistory].</i> Malden, something a Roman Emperor had not done for about a centuryMA: Blackwell Pub.</ref>
In fact, Marcus Aurlieus appointed his son as successor long before he died in 166 The Colosseum (he died Figure 1) was the premier event for gladiator contests after its construction in 180 70-80 CE). Ambitious trainers, making similar to how the film depicts it clear , would try to situate themselves to compete in main events that Comodus was his choice all alongpromised large financial rewards. He also died in Vienna (ancient Vindobona)Like sport today, but the film showed him dying in Germania during gladiator games had a lot of money exchange hands around the campaignevents. Some rumors and stories did circulate that Commodus did kill his father, This revolved around gambling on the matches but this could have been later stories created to malign also rewarded the emperor Commodus since he was not well liked by owners from the Senategladiator slaves, as suggested in which is one reason why the filmmass killing of gladiators may not have occurred that often. The appointment of Commodus was controversial, as shown in <ref>For more on the filmColosseum and venues for gladiator contests, as Commodus was considered erratic and may have had mental problemssee: Aldrete, as suggested in the filmG. S. (2008). <i>[https://www.amazon. From historical documents, mainly com/gp/product/0806140275/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=0806140275&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=49b67742ce99855243d1ef3bdb379b40 Daily life in the writings of Cassius DioRoman city: Rome, there is indication that Marcus Aurlieus was disappointed in his sonPompeii, suggesting he had some trepidation about himand Ostia] (Oklahoma paperback ed).</i> Norman: Univ. However, it is hard to tell what is exactly accurate as Commodus may have been more disliked by the upper classes, while some indication suggests he was actually popular with the armyof Oklahoma Press.</ref>
==The Gladiator Contests==<dh-ad/>
In Something not shown in the film, after Maximus was taken as a slave, but not before he discovered is that his wife and son gladiator contests may have looked familiar to us. Gladiators often were killed by Commodusused to sponsoring products, he was shown as being transported and eventually enslaved as a gladiator in a far away eastern province billboards often hung in the Roman Empire (somewhere stadium where contests would have been held. These advertisements were not shown in the Middle East or North Africa). While the circumstances of how Commodus became emperor in film, mostly because the producers thought film are probably audiences would not true, there believe it since it is greater truth in some of the gladiator fightsso similar to our modern sports. <ref>For instance, gladiator contests did often reconstruct famous battles or scenes using characters from history or legends. Gladiator contests did take place more on advertising in many places around the empire. AnimalsRoman world, such as tigerssee: Bomgardner, were often used in arenas, where gladiators might fight each other as well as animalsD. L. In fact, excavations at the Colosseum showed a variety of exotic animals were present there(2002). This included<i>[https: bears, lions, hyena, elephant, wild boar, buffalo, tigers, bulls, wolves, and leopards//www.amazon. com/gp/product/0415301858/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=0415301858&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=23f8ea6b9900470adc695008478dd264 The clothing story of the gladiators depictedRoman amphitheater].</i> London; New York: Routledge, particularly the helmets, were likely not true and were stereotypes taken from later periodspg. 55.</ref>
GladiatorsIn the film, after Maximus was captured trying to revolt against the emperor. He was shown as fighting the emperor in a one on one contest. This match would have never happened. First, Commodus died in a coup event in 192 rather than at Maximus's hand, as suggested shown in the final combat scene in the film. Second, were treated like rock starts. Those who were successful could gain favorsCommodus, such as having access to women and even earn their freedom. However, unlike shown in the filmmovie, often contests did not result fight in the death of contestantsarena. AnimalsHowever, he probably only fought in fact, were often killed in contestsevents where he has assured victories against animals or crippled captives. This may have been de-emphasized in the The filmdoes suggest this as Commodus does mortally wound Maximus before their fight when Maximus was tied and unable to defend himself.
The Colosseum was the premier event for gladiator contests after its construction in 70-80 CE. Ambitious trainersNevertheless, similar historians indicate he liked to how the film depicts itthink of himself as Hercules, would try and even began to situate themselves so they could compete dress like him in main events that promised large financial rewards. Similar to sport todaygladiator contests rather than as the emperor, where he wore bright emperor clothing in the gladiator games had a lot of money that would exchange hands around the eventfilm. This revolved around gambling <ref>For more on the events but also rewards earned by the owners of the Commodus' gladiator slaves.contests, see: Adams 2013: 242</ref>
Something not shown in the film is that gladiator contests may have looked familiar to us. Gladiators often were used to sponsor products and billboards often hung in stadium where contests would have been held. This was not shown in the film, mostly because the producers thought audience would not believe it since it is so similar to our modern sports.<div class="portal" style='float:right; width:35%'>
In the film, after Maximus was capture trying to revolt against the emperor. He was shown as fighting the emperor as a one on one contest. This would have certainly never happened. First, Commodus died in a coup event in 192 rather than at the hand of Maximus, as shown in the final combat scene in the film. Second, Commodus, as shown in the film, did fight in the arena, although he probably only fought in events where he was assured victory such as against animals or crippled captives. The film does suggest this as Commodus does mortally wound Maximus before their fight, when Maximus was tied and unable to defend himself. Nevertheless, historians indicate he liked to think of himself as Hercules, and even began to dress like him in gladiator contests====Related DailyHistory.org Articles===={{#dpl:category=Roman History|ordermethod=firstedit|order=descending|count=12}}</div>
==Main CharactersWho was Maximus Decimus Meridius Based On?==<u>Maximus Decimus Meridius</u>: Maximus is an entirely fictitious character but seems to be based on several characters, including Avidius Cassius, a general in Marcus Aurelius' armies. He declared himself emperor shortly after thinking Aurelius died in 175, suggesting a brief power struggle. Still, he was eventually killed after it became clear Aurelius was not dead. A general named Maximus lived in the late Roman Empire who may have inspired Gladiator's story of a revolt against an emperor.<ref>For more on Avidius, see: Canduci, Alexander (2010). <i>Triumph & Tragedy: The Rise and Fall of Rome’s Immortal Emperors.</i> Roman imperial biographies. Sydney: Pier 9.</ref>
==Who were the Real People portrayed in Gladiator?==<u>Maximus Decimus MeridiusCommodus</u>: Maximus While Commodus is an entirely fictitious charactera historical figure who did hold gladiator contests and may have been mentally unstable, but seems to be based on several charactersas depicted in the film, including Avidius Cassiushe did, who was a general in Marcus Aurelius' armies. In fact, he rule the Roman Empire for 12 years. Among the odd things Commodus did declare was rename the months and legions after himself emperor shortly after Aurelius' death, suggesting a brief power struggle, but (he had twelve names he was eventually killedwent by). There was a general He even named Maximus who lived in the late Roman Empire who people after himself. He was purported to have held naked gladiator contests, which would have outraged some Roman citizens and contributed to his bad reputation and eventual downfall. He may have aspired to revolt against killed 100 lions in a day during his gladiator contests and other exotic animals such as elephants. Even by Roman standards, the empirelevel of slaughter may have caused outrage.
<u>Commodus</u>: While Commodus is a historical figure who did hold gladiator contests and may have been mentally unstable, as depicted in the film, he did, in fact, rule for 12 years. Among the odd things Commodus did was rename the months and legions after himself (he had twelve names he went by). He even named the Roman people after himself. He was purported to have held naked gladiator contests, which would have outraged some Roman citizens and may have contributed to his bad reputation and eventual downfall. He may have killed 100 lions in a day during his gladiator contests and other exotic animals such as elephants. Even by Roman standards, the level of slaughter may have caused outrage. He even started killing crippled many disabled people in the arena, which may have been on one of the final straws before his own assassinationhe was assassinated. However, his political actions were also likely unwise, as he . He tried to declare himself consul and gladiator, where the former is an elected position and the later something latter usually only slaves should hold. Narcissus, his wrestling partner, eventually killed him in 192 as part of a larger conspiracyby Roman leaders.<ref>For more on Commodus, see: Adams 2013. </ref>
<u>Lucilla</u>: She was Commodus' sister , and in the film , she was depicted as trying to encourage the conspiracy against her brother. She did, in fact, conspire to kill Commodus but failed in 182, leading to her death. Unlike what the film depicts, Lucilla was probably ambitious to be a co-ruler with her husband(she is shown as a widow in the movie), which is why she may have conspiredagainst her brother. However, she may not have not considered herself as a possible ruler until she witnessed her erratic brother's behavior. Unlike the film, Commodus probably did not try seek to have incestous relations an incestuous relationship with his sister.<ref>For more on Lucilla, see: Lightman, M., Lightman, B., & Lightman, M. (2008).<i>[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0816031126/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=0816031126&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=e0745e365189f3743bd8492787d85ed5 A to Z of Ancient Greek and Roman women].</i> (Rev. ed). New York: Facts On File, pg. 195.</ref>
<u>Marcus Aurelius</u>: The emperor's relatively positive reputation has likely contributed to his depiction in the film as a wise ruler (i.e., the philosopher-king) who tried to avoid appointing his son. However, the destructive character of despite his son may have caused later depictions of 's destructive nature, Marcus Aurelius not being content with was willing to choose Commodus to be his son succeeding himsuccessor and heir. The film depicts Marcus Aurelius lamenting his many wars, but in reality , Marcu Aurelius would have seen these wars as his duty to Rome. He was influenced by stoic Stoic philosophy, which believed in wisdom, courage, justice , and temperance.<ref>For more on Marcus Aurelius as the philosopher-king, see: McLynn, F. (2010). <i>[https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1844135276/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=1844135276&linkCode=as2&tag=dailyh0c-20&linkId=b7e495cc41272b5a97414fb499bdbe9c Marcus Aurelius: Warrior, philosopher, emperor].</i> London: Vintage Books.</ref>
==Conclusion and Accuracy==
There were many historical inaccuracies in the film. The historians who were hired to advise the movie quit or refused to be given credits because of the many historical inaccuracies the final version had. Nevertheless, as with most historical dramas, this movie was more about entertainment than historical narrative.
 
The overall narrative of a somewhat crazy emperor in Commodus was correct. Oddly enough, the reality of Commodus' reign was probably more outrageous than what was shown in the film, as the emperor often made himself dress as a gladiator and fought numerous contests with animals and others, such as wounded gladiators.
 
If you want to learn more about gladiators, check out our article [[How Did Gladiatorial Games Evolve in Ancient Rome?]] for more information.
 
====References====
<references/>
==References=={{Contributors}}[[Category:Wikis]][[Category:Ancient History]] [[Category:Historically Accurate]] [[Category:Roman History]]

Navigation menu