How did Mussolini become Prime Minister of Italy?


Benito Mussolini

Benito Mussolini came to power in 1922. At first, he ruled in a democratic and constitutional manner, but in 1925, he turned Italy into a one-party, totalitarian state, with himself as sole leader. He would forcefully govern Italy until 1943 when the Allied invasion of the country led to his downfall. His rise to power was remarkable. He went from being a journalist and a minor political figure to becoming prime minister of Italy within the space of five years. His remarkable rise was abetted by the fear of a communist revolution and that allowed Mussolini and his fascist party to seize power, with little opposition.

Background

Prior to 1914, Mussolini was a committed socialist. [1] However, when the socialists adopted a policy of neutrality in World War One, Mussolini opposed it and was later expelled from the party [2]. Mussolini was a well-known journalist and had strongly advocated for Italy’s entrance into the war in his newspaper, in 1914. Mussolini was an Italian Nationalist and he wanted to unify his country, he regularly employed nationalist rhetoric that portrayed Italy as a great power in order to eliminate regional loyalties that had kept the country divided despite the official unification of the country in 1871.

When Italy did enter the war on the side of the Allies in 1915, Mussolini volunteered and served with distinction on the front. He was severely injured in 1917 and was forced to leave the army.[3] Mussolini, like Hitler, Mussolini was deeply influenced by the war and he came to believe that war was essential for a nation, as it would allow it and its people to achieve greatness. Later on as leader of Italy, he would seize every opportunity to become involved in war and conflict. The war also confirmed Mussolini in his belief that action mattered more than debate and reason, and this was central to his fascist ideology, in turn, this led to the glorification of violence.[4]

After the war, Mussolini found the Italian Fascist Party. The ideology of the party was a fusion of socialism and nationalism. The Party called for a strong nation led by an elite to guide Italy and to solve its interminable social and economic problems.[5] Mussolini’s new party was attractive to many and especially ex-soldiers. The party soon had genuine mass appeal and much of this was based on Mussolini's calls that all Italians unite and overcome their class differences.[6] As the war ended there were many war veterans who joined the new Fascist Party and believed that it offered the best hope for Italy. Many of these men were unemployed after the war and they felt that their sacrifices during the war had been in vain. Mussolini cleverly formed squadrons of these veterans and employed them against all those he declared to be the enemies of Italy. These squads of former soldiers became known as ‘Blackshirts’ and they proved to be a formidable paramilitary force.[7]

Impact of World War I

Italy’s military performed dismally during the war and had sustained extremely high casualties and there had been also mass desertions. Many people and especially soldiers were disenchanted with the political class’ handling of the war. They were widely seen as corrupt and ineffective and many held them personally responsible for the country's failings during the war. The Italian political system, though technically a democracy was in reality dominated by the traditional landowning and business elite. [8] The Italians had entered into the First World War on the side of the Allies and they had been promised new territories and colonies. Many Italians had supported the country’s entry into the war in the belief that Italy would finally be elevated to a major European power by acquiring colonies. After the Treaty of Versailles, the Italians, though technically on the winning side, were not accorded equal status as the other major allied states such as France and the United Kingdom.[9] Furthermore, the country did not receive the territories or the new colonies that many Italians, they had been promised and it soon appears that the country's sacrifices during the war, were all in vain and pointless.[10] The Italian middle class, which was very nationalistic were especially disappointed and many grow disenchanted with the country's democratic model of government and came to believe that it could never truly unite the nation and establish it as a world power, like France or Britain.

Like many Germans, Italians believed that the nation had been betrayed by the old political elite. The general population, especially the Italian middle-class, became increasingly disenchanted with the nation’s political class and system. [11] Mussolini never lost an opportunity to denounce the political class, and this increased his popularity. The end of the war also led to a major economic crisis in Italy. Unemployment was widespread, as was hunger, especially among the urban poor and in the South of Italy. This made the Italian political class and even the King, Victor Emanuelle III, extremely unpopular. By 1920, the old political parties were deeply unpopular and there was a widespread sense in Italian society that change or some revolution was needed to save the country.[12] The postwar economic and political circumstances in Italy created a great deal or unrest and disillusionment and Mussolini was fully prepared to exploit the opportunities.

Fascist Organizations and use of violence

By 1920, Mussolini and his fascists were a force to be reckoned with in the land, especially in the industrial north. Within a short span of time, Mussolini and his party were almost a state within a state. they were soon running a parallel administration in many towns.There were several reasons for the quick and apparently inexorable rise of Mussolini and his part, firstly there was no leadership at the national or state level. The Italian government was divided, as the country's democratic parties could not come together. the Italian Liberal party and the Catholic Party refused to work together, because of the issue of Church-State relations in Italy. This meant that the country lacked a strong government in the vital period of the war and this in turn allowed the Fascists to become a powerful force in the land.[13]

Then there was the fact that many in the government, civil service, and the army were conservatives and somewhat sympathetic to the aims and the rhetoric of Mussolini and were attracted to his ideology. This and the weakness of the government meant that Mussolini was rapidly able to build up his power in the country. Then there was the fact that Mussolini and his Fascists used violence and terror to gain control The Black Shirt Squads w used violence to intimidate, torture or even kill those who opposed the will of Mussolini.They were feared by many, however, many in the confused post-war period saw them as a source of stability and security and this won them a measure of popular support, among many in the middle class.[14]

The Rise of Communism

Benito Mussolini and the March on Rome, 1922

The radical left was particularly strong in Italy during the Great War, as it benefitted from the unpopularity of the government, and the war among the poor and the working class. In 1917, the Italian Socialist Party allied itself with the Soviet Union and agitated for a revolution in Italy. Industrial workers in the major Italian cities had formed themselves into powerful trade unions. They frequently went on strike, during the difficult war years, and were often brutally repressed by the Italian police and armies.[15] After the end of the First World War, many cities were paralyzed by these strikes and these actions greatly alarmed the middle class and wealthy Italians.

The strikers were usually supported by the Italian Socialists and many politicians and commentators believed that there was a real threat of a Russian style revolution in Italy. Mussolini played upon these fears and exaggerated the threat of a Communist revolution.[16] The Italian middle class was very concerned about the rise of Communism and Socialism because they believed that in any revolution, that they would have their property seized as had been the case in Russia. Many Italians were Catholics and the rise of the 'Reds' or Socialists was viewed with horror, as they were frequently anti-Catholic and anti-religious. [17]

From 1919, Mussolini’s Fascist Black Shirts fought with Socialists and others in the streets of Italy. The Black Shirt squads were very effective and they managed to break many strikes and intimidated, injured and killed many socialists and trade unionists. This made them very popular among those who feared a revolution. This meant that many in the Italian middle class and elite began to see the Fascists as capable of saving Italy from a 'Red' revolution as in Russia. However, many, even some conservatives were not in favor of Mussolini and his party, but he was seen as the lesser of two evils and anything was better than Communism and Socialism for many upper-class Italians.[18]

Fascist Propaganda

The Fascists presented themselves as the saviors of Italy by Mussolini who was a skillful propagandist. Propaganda is a method of persuading people to do things and commit actions to further some interest group or faction. Mussolini was a pioneer in its use and an admiring Adolf Hitler would model his public speaking on Mussolini. the leader of the Italian Fascists was a charismatic speaker and he spoke in an emotive style that appealed to Italians and this won him many supporters. The Fascists used a series of symbols to associate themselves with Rome and the glories of Italy's past. The party was actually named after the Roman symbol of justice - the Fascii.[19] The use of symbols of such symbols appealed to many Italians at a time when they felt that their nation had been humiliated in the war and by the Treaty of Versailles. Above all, it was Mussolini's anti-communist rhetoric that won him a substantial following in Italy, among all classes. It seems that the majority of Italians, the middle class, the elite and Catholics, all feared communism, in particular, and lived in fear of a revolution. Mussolini was able to portray himself and his party as the defenders of Italy as the only one's who could save the country from the red menace.[20]

March on Rome

Fascists March on Rome

However, Mussolini though increasingly popular was unable to secure power through constitutional means. The Italian Fascist party only won 35 seats in the election of 1921, far less than the Socialists. Still, Mussolini was determined to win power for himself and his Party. The coalition government was very unpopular and during a period of instability, the Fascists descended on Rome in their thousands, to demand the resignation of the Prime Minister. [21] Some 30,000 Blackshirts traveled from all over Italy demanding a change in the government. This became known as the ‘March on Rome’.

Typical of Mussolini the event was stage managed and theatrical. The Black Shirts were well drilled and disciplined. This was a deliberate policy of demonstrating that the Fascists were a force that supported law and order and the opposite of the Communists and Socialists who were seen as dangerous and destabilizing. During the March on Rome, Mussolini made sure he was photographed with the marchers and made many speeches when he repeatedly stated that Itlay was in danger and that only he and his party could save the country. the March on Rome was a piece of theater designed to win him and his party the popular support they needed to seize the government of the country. The Fascists arrived in Rome and many wondered what would occur. Mussolini and others feared that there would be bloodshed and that the army would fire on the marchers.[22]

A conspiracy?

The Italian army and police could easily have dispersed the Blackshirts, who were unarmed. However, they were allowed to congregate in Rome and they forced the government from power and Mussolini became Prime Minister of Italy.[23] Many argued at the time and since that this was part of a strategy by the Italian Monarchy, army, landowners, industrialists and the Catholic Church to allow Mussolini to seize power. They were so afraid of an imminent revolution led by Socialists or Communists that they allowed the Fascist to take power. Many in the conservative elite believed that Mussolini was the only alternative to a ‘Red Revolution.’[24] They did not really like Mussolini but believed that he could secure their interests and prevent the country from a Soviet-style revolution. However, they believed that they could manage him and that he would agree not to interfere with their privileges. When Mussolini became Prime Minister he set about to create a one-party state. However, he did not attempt to interfere with the interests of the Monarchy, army, church and other members of the elite, who had allowed him to seize power. This was their reward for allowing Mussolini to become the undisputed leader of Italy ‘Il Duce.’ [25]

Conclusion

The Italian Fascists would later portray their seizure of power as a ‘revolution’. In fact, powerful elites in Italy allowed them to take power in 1921. This was part of their strategy to ensure that Italy did not become a Socialist or Communist country. This was crucial in the establishment of the Fascist government. Without the fear of a ‘Red Revolution’ the Italian army, monarchy, and others would not have allowed Mussolini to assume power in Rome. Mussolini and the Fascists were not the most popular grouping in Italy and they could never have come to power by purely democratic means. The fear of Communism meant that they were permitted to assume power and stay in power.

References

  1. John Whittam. Fascist Italy. (Manchester, England; New York, New York, USA: Manchester University Press, 2006). p. 165.
  2. Whittam, p. 166
  3. Whittam, p. 117.
  4. Kallis, Aristotle. 2000. Fascist Ideology( London, Routledge 2000)p. 45.
  5. Anthony James Gregor (1979). Young Mussolini and the Intellectual Origins of Fascism. University of California Press, p. 111
  6. Kallis, p. 9
  7. Kallis, p. 45
  8. Gregor, 1979, p. 56
  9. John Whittam. Fascist Italy. Manchester, England; New York, New York, USA: Manchester University Press. p. 165.
  10. Gregor, 1979 , p. 117.
  11. Whitham, p. 117
  12. De Grand, Alexander. Italian Fascism: Its Origins and Development. Oxford University Press: Oxford, p. 87’ (1989)
  13. Kallis, p. 167
  14. Gregor, p. 134
  15. De Grand, p. 78
  16. De Grand, Alexander. The Hunchback's Tailor: Giovanni Giolitti and Liberal Italy from the Challenge of Mass Politics to the Rise of Fascism, 1882–1922(2001), p. 89
  17. De Grand, p 98
  18. De Grand, p. 101
  19. De Grand, p. 123
  20. De Grand, p. 121
  21. Farrell, Nicholas. Mussolini: A New Life. London: Phoenix Press, 2003, p. 154
  22. Farrell, p. 155
  23. Bosworth, Richard J. B. Mussolini's Italy (2005). p. 89
  24. Bosworth, p. 101
  25. Bosworth, p. 99

Contributors

Admin and Ewhelan